HOME
PHOTO GALLERY
RKAGAN'S HOME PAGE
QUESTIONS
OTHER
 
   

Richard C. Kagan

Professor of History, Hamline University
St. Paul, Minnesota 55104 USA
651.523-2433 (ph) E-mail rkagan@hamline.edu


Lecture: Genocide in Cambodia

(Hit the Back Button on your browser window to return to the Lectures' Website when done)

 
Genocide in Cambodia
Lecture June 23, 2000 -- University of Minnesota
All publications posted on this site are copyrighted and can only be used with the legal written consent of Richard Kagan. Questions can be directed to Richard Kagan

LECTURE ON GENOCIDE IN CAMBODIA.
DATE LECTURE GIVEN:
JUNE 23, 2000- UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA

OUTLINE:

Description of the killings.

Chronology

  • Major political leaders
  • Saloth Sar (Pol Pot) 1925-1998. Naming. Labeling. Personality. Education.
  • Prince Sihanouk
  • Lon Nol
  • Hun Sen

Definitions of genocide

  • Ethnic-Vietnamese-Cambodians, Vietnamese
  • Class-Bourgeois, urban, new citizens, Khmer elite
  • Religious-Cham

Questionable definitions

  • Autogenocide
  • Political
  • Failed agricultural, social and political policies.
Debated issues:

Was it genocide? Richard Solomon, the major negotiator for the U.S. State Dept. in Southeast Asia referred to the killings not as genocide, but as being "the kind of violence that Pol Pot perpetrated.

"#s killed. Kiernan vs. other analysts.
The politics of counting. On whose behalf?
Situations of death. Tuol Seng, The Killing Fields. Executions of "enemy troops."

Narrative of the Genocide:
The Cambodian Communist Movement: View of history. Sense of dependence and isolation. Khmer Rouge.

  • Marxist Theory.
  • Vietnamese Communist Party tutelage.
  • Separating from the above.
  • Adopting Maoism and Kim Il-sung
The Vietnam War.
Resentment of Vietnamese tutelage.

1973, January. Accord between U.S. and Vietnam. End of bombing in Vietnam. The beginning of bombing in Cambodia. 6 months. Vietnamese pull out of Cambodia.

Saloth Sar. Three military campaigns against Pnom Penh. #1. Sent about 2 million refugees into the capital. Communists destroyed by American bombing. 10,000 Communist deaths.

#2. Attack on a provincial capital near Vietnam. Repulsed by Cambodian troops. More refugees.

#3. Attack on the capital. Help from Chinese. April 19th. Capital was taken.

Democratic Kampuchea.

Domestic policies:

  • Removal of urban population
  • Abolish money, markets, newspapers, reading materials.
  • All dress in black
  • Erasure of names
  • No humor. Modeled on the Cultural Revolution and Kim Il-sung's reign.
  • Loyalty to the central govt.
  • Year Zero.
  • Hard labor. Communalization. Raise population.
  • Wipe out enemies. Defined by class, ethnicity, educational level, and failure to produce.
  • Self-sufficiency. Re-writing of Khmer history.
Diplomatic policies:
  • Keep up relations with Sihanouk as long as he is supported by the Chinese. After a year, Sihanouk is placed under house arrest.
  • Close relations with China and North Korea.
  • Belief in the spread of anti-Vietnamese [communist] states in So. East Asia and Africa. Sponsored by China and N. Korea.
  • 1978. Fear of Vietnamese invasion. Invitation to Dudman, Becker, and Caldwell. Talks with Pol Pot. Murder of Caldwell. Two weeks later, Vietnam invades Cambodia.

International real politick.

China: Reserved support of North Vietnam. 1954. Geneva Accords. Split with U.S.S.R.. 1965. Pol Pot visits Beijing. Support. 1973. Deng supports Pol Pot.

Beijing sends troops to invade (teach a lesson to) Vietnam in January of 79. 15,000 deaths. Retreats. China sets up base camps in Thailand and Western Cambodia to provide economic and military aid to Pol Pot. China is strongest supporter of Pol Pot.

Thailand: Military and financial support. Timber, and minerals. Refugee camps controlled by Pol Pot. Keeps revolution out of Thailand.

U.S. Pol Pot is not considered as a Marxist. He did not commit genocide. He is a significant factor in the Cold War and in keeping Vietnam in isolation. C.I.A. has a base camp to provide aid. Great debate in U.S. Congress over aid.

Boat people vs. displaced people; Vietnamese vs. Cambodians. The plight of the Hmong.

The Vietnamese controlled Cambodia could not receive any UN or International Aid. All aid, very paltry, was from the USSR.

1988-9: Great international changes. A new Prime Minister in Thailand, Chatichai, met with Hun Sen. Changed Thailand's policies. A banker. Economic development of Camb.

Vietnam would leave in '89. This created a crisis. Who would rule Cambodia.

P-5 Work out new government. Three of the five were China scholars-Solomon for the U.S. and Martin for France. Even the Russian rep. was a China scholar. and , of course, the rep. from China was biased to China. No one represented the Cambodians or the Vietnamese. The Americans and Chinese wanted Pol Pot to be included in the new government. Fear was that Vietnam would control the new govt. by proxy. . An arrangement finally made which did not allow Pol Pot to be in the government, but did allow some of his influence. America makes the elections the pre-requisite for recognizing Vietnam. Hanoi needs Western support. Can't do much about Cambodian politics.

UN takes over. Prepares for elections. 2 Billion dollars. Ethnic violence. Vietnamese laborers. Inflation. No military. Political killings and banditry.

The UN runs the country in preparation for elections. Sihanouk was brought back from exile in China and North Korea. His son ran for the office of P.M. But he was kicked out by Hun Sen who controlled the Arm. Hun Sen kills opposition members. Gives immunity to Pol Pot's main advisors. They surrender and bring troops over to Hun Sen.

Pol Pot "discovered" in 1997 by Nate Thayer. Dies of "natural" causes in 1998. Body is burned.

Current situation:

  • Battle over the investigation of the Killing Fields. Ben Kiernan and the Republican Congress.
  • International War Crimes Tribunal: U.S. vs. Cambodia over jurisdiction.
  • Autobiographies, journals, analysis.
  • What have we learned?
  • The causes of genocide?
  • The role of international agencies and organizations?
  • The role of states?
  • The nature of terror and killing?
  • How to describe an event like the Killing Fields?
A Brief Chronology

9th Century to 14th Century: The Angkor era in Cambodia. The Khmer kingdom.

1863-1864: King Norodom signs treaties beginning the era of the French protectorate over Cambodia, which lasts until 1953.

1925: Birth of "Pol Pot"

1930: Ho Chi Minh founds the Indochinese Communist Party with responsibility over Vietnam, Cambodia, and Laos.

1941: The Japanese march into Phnom Penh.
Sihanouk is crowned king by the Vichy french.

1945:. The Japanese remove the vichy French in Cambodia in a coup de force and grant Cambodia its "independence" under Sihanouk.

WWII ends: Sihanouk invites the French back.

1949: Pol Pot (Saloth Sar) travels to Paris for studies and stays until 1963 when he returns to Cambodia as a communist.

1951: The Khmer People's Revolutionary Party is created out of the Indochinese Communist Party.

1953: Sihanouk wins limited independence from France.

1954: The Geneva Conference gives complete control over an independent Cambodia.
Many Cambodian Communists flee to Vietnam.

1955: Cambodia holds an election. Sihanouk abdicates and sweeps the election.

1960: Formation of the Communist Party in Phnom Penh.

1963: Saloth Sar (Pol Pot) becomes head of the party. Party leaders leave the capital to organize in the countryside-near the Vietnamese border.

1965: Sihanouk breaks relations with U.S. and in

1966: Allows Vietnamese communists to use the Ho Chi Minh trail in Cambodia.

1967-70: Sihanouk wages a small scale war against Communist insurgents.

1969: The U.S. mounts secret, illegal bombing campaign against Vietnamese targets inside Cambodian border area.

1970: Sihanouk is deposed by Lon Nol.
Sihanouk forms the National United Front of Kampuchea which includes the Khmer Rouge.
The Khmer Republic is proclaimed in Phnom Penh.

1971: The North Vietnamese defeat the Cambodian Army. This Army never fully recovers.

1972: Lon Nol is elected president of the Khmer Republic.

1973: The Paris agreement ending the war in Vietnam is signed but the Cambodian communists refuse to negotiate. The Vietnamese Army returns to Vietnam, leaving the Khmer Rouge to fight on its own.

  • March? The U.S. begins massive bombing of Cambodia. In August the U.S. Congress ends the bombing campaign.

1974: Lass full year of the war. The Khmer Rouge begin purges.

1975 : April 17. Khmer Rouge march into Phnom Penh. Evacuation begins.

  • April 30: The Vietnamese Communists take Saigon.
  • May 12: Mayaguez is captured.

1976: Establishment of Democratic Kampuchea. Pol Pot is PM. Mao Tse-tung dies and Pol Pot temporarily leaves office. Purges of all those with ties to Vietnam, and those in the northern zone.

1977: Purges within the party. Border clashes with Thailand and Vietnam.
Because Vietnam signs a friendship agreement with Laos, Cambodia declares Vietnam to be an enemy.
Pol Pot finally declares publicly that his country is communist. He proceeds to China and North Korea revealing he is really Saloth Sar.
Border war with Vietnam. On Dec. 31, Cambodia suspends relations with Vietnam.

1978: Cambodia declares victory over Vietnamese agents and soldiers in Cambodia.
Vietnam decides to invade Cambodia.
Purge of the Eastern Zone.
Malcolm Caldwell is murdered.

  • December 22: Vietnam launches its offensive.
1979. January 7: The Vietnamese capture Phnom Penh.
Vietnam establishes a puppet government.
Pol Pot and his followers flee to Thai border. Establish a guerrilla base in Pailin.
Receive support from China. Also sell minerals and timber (est. millions of dollars per month) to Thailand.
  • February: China invades northern Vietnam in support of Pol Pot.
  • October: The Khmer govt. of Democratic Kampuchea retains Cambodia's seat in the U.N.

1981: The UN only recognizes Pol Pot's government.

1982: Sihanouk and former Premier Son Sann join the Khmer Rouge in a new Coalition Government of Democratic Kampuchea. The Association of Southeast Asian States is the official sponsor.

1985: After four years of fighting, the Vietnamese Army consolidates its hold on all of Cambodia except for the Pailin area.

1986: Gorbachev seeks a peaceful resolution to the Cambodian crisis.

1987: Sihanouk and P.M. Hun Sen meet for the first time to discuss a peace settlement.

1988: January. Second meeting. No results.

  • May: Vietnam announces that it will withdraw 50% of its troops by December.
    Sihanouk resigns from Pol Pot's government claiming that the Khmer Rouge are killing his followers.
    Thailand's Prime Minister, Chatichai announces plan to transform Indochina from "a battlefield into a market place."

1989: International meetings to agree on a peace in Cambodia, and to a unified government. Vietnamese troops will leave at the end of the year.

  • September 21: Vietnam pulls out its last troops. Announces that 53,500 soldiers died since 1978. Almost as many as American soldiers who died in the Vietnam war.
  • November 8: 6 weeks after Vietnam's announcement, the West-through the British Foreign Secretary-finally announces the pull out.
1990: The P-5 ( the five permanent members of the Security Council) meet in Paris to discuss a settlement of the Cambodian crisis. They agree to discuss the Australian plan that would rely heavily on the U.N.
  • March: proposal for UNTAC-The United Nations Transition Authority in Cambodia.
    More talks. Khmer Rouge boycotts some.
  • July 18: U.S. Secretary of State James Baker drops support for Pol Pot's UN membership. For the first time will sponsor a dialogue with Vietnam on Cambodia to bring a settlement and prevent the Khmer Rouge from returning to power.
  • August 22: The Chinese force the Khmer rouge to agree to the P-5 formula. The new Supreme National Council is awarded the UN seat.

1991: The war with Iraq takes pressure off the Khmer rouge. 2/23. The Thai military stage a coup d'etat against P.M. Chatichai.
Sihanouk chairs the Supreme National Council and Hun Sen is vice hair. Sihanouk returns to Phnom Penh for the first time since he fled in January 1979.
Diplomatic relations are forged between Vietnam and China, Cambodia and Vietnam,
Sihanouk addresses the U.N.

1992: The UN sets up shop in Cambodia. Yasushi Akashi is civilian head.
Khmer Rouge charges the UN with favoring Hun Sen. They announce that the UN cannot enter their territory or oversee their disarmament.
UN oversees return of 370,000 refugees. Registers 4.8 million voters.

1993: Khmer Rouge does not register to participate in elections..

  • May 23: Prince Norodom Ranariddh, son of Prince Sihanouk, won 45 percent of the vote. Hun Sen won 38 percent despite its organized intimidation. Hun Sen's forces begin a wave of terror against the UN and the opposition. The young Prince agrees to a joint rule with Hun Sen.
  • September: Sihanouk is crowned the King of Cambodia.

1996: Ieng Sary, a high Khmer Rouge official, defects to Hun Sen with 15,000 troops. Ieng is allowed undisputed control over Pailin.

1997: Pol Pot orders the brutal murder of his top aide, Son Sen, because of defections which have eaten up over half of the Khmer rouge soldiers.

  • July: Foreign governments cajole the Khmer Rouge to turn over Pol Pot for trial.
    Hun Sen stages a coup against the young Prince claiming that he is too close to the Khmer Rouge.
  • August: The Khmer rouge put Pol Pot on trial for treason. This is to show the West that Pol Pot is no longer in charge and that the West can negotiate with the Khmer Rouge.
  • October: The Khmer Rouge allow journalist Nate Thayer to interview Pol Pot who refuses to acknowledge any wrongdoing.

1998. April 15: The few remaining Khmer Rouge leaders announce that Pol Pot has died in his sleep of a heart attack at the age of 73. Pol Pot is cremated three days later.

1999-2000: Debates on whether and how to bring Khmer Rouge leaders to trial.

 
© 2003. Updated at May, 2003 Best View I.E. 800 X 600