X-URL: http://www.thejakartapost.com:8890/iscp_render?menu_name=hitlist_details&id=1805275
IBRA loses another legal fight against defaulters
Business News - June 16, 2000
JAKARTA (JP): The Supreme Court has rejected a bankruptcy appeal filed
by the Indonesian Bank Restructuring Agency (IBRA) against palm oil
producer PT Sumi Asih, marking another failure in the agency's legal
battles against debt defaulters.
Sustaining the Jakarta Commercial Court's late April ruling, the
Supreme Court ruled that IBRA should file the law suit at the district
court instead of at the bankruptcy court.
"Because the case requires a complicated proving process of evidence,
it should be filed at the district court, instead of the bankruptcy
court," the Supreme Court's ruling said.
IBRA has, so far, filed bankruptcy suits with the commercial court
against five uncooperative debtors but none of the cases have been won
by IBRA .
They are PT Tirtamas Comexindo, PT Westkalindo Pulp Papermill, PT A
Latief Corporation (out-of-court settlement), PT Ometraco Corporation
and PT Sumi Asih.
The Supreme Court ruling, dated June 8, was signed by a panel of
judges chaired by Supreme Justice Paulus E. Lotulung.
The ruling stressed that there were differing views between IBRA and
Sumi Asih on the amount of matured debts Sumi Asih owed to IBRA,
adding, "It is beyond the jurisdiction of the bankruptcy court to make
a ruling on this issue."
The Supreme Court ruling stated the resolution on the dispute about
the different views in the amount of debts would take a complicated
and timely process of evidence proving, which is not within the
jurisdiction of the bankruptcy court, which has a limited time frame
in deciding a case.
The 1998 Bankruptcy Law stipulates that the bankruptcy court must
decide a case within a period of not more than 30 days.
The law also stresses that the bankruptcy court, unlike a district
court, adopts the principle of simply proving the evidence.
IBRA filed a bankruptcy suit against Sumi Asih at the Jakarta
Commercial Court in late March for not paying matured debts worth Rp
25 billion and US$6.2 million.
Sumi Asih, however, disputed the accuracy of the amount of unpaid
debts, saying it should be much lower than the above claimed.
The Jakarta Commercial Court accepted Sumi Asih's dispute and rejected
IBRA's bankruptcy suit in late April. IBRA then filed an appeal with
the Supreme Court.
IBRA's legal division head, Agustus Sani Nugroho, said earlier that
IBRA, like many other parties, had expressed great concerns against
"funny" verdicts made by the country's courts on bankruptcy cases.
"The point is not that the creditor always has to win the case, but
legal certainty is at stake here," he said.
Bankruptcy lawyer Andrey Sitanggang said creditors often lost a case
due to an "X" factor, not a legal factor.
"Creditors are often frustrated by illogical ruling," Andrey said.
In another case at the Jakarta Commercial Court, majority creditors of
publicly listed PT Anwar Sierad voted to approve the debt
restructuring proposed by the company, but with a few conditions
attached.
The debt restructuring agreement involved a debt to equity swap and a
15- year tenor bond issuance.
Set as prerequisites to the debt restructuring agreement by the
creditors are the completion of a planned merger between Anwar Sierad
with its sister company, PT Sierad Produced.
The creditors also said the debt restructuring agreement would be
automatically canceled if Anwar Sierad's other sister companies,
namely, Sierad Produce and Sierad Grain (currently filed for
bankruptcy) were declared bankrupt.
Still another case at the commercial court is state owned PT Dok &
Perkapalan Kodja Bahari, which managed to survive a bankruptcy threat
for the fourth time on Wednesday, when the Jakarta Commercial Court
rejected a bankruptcy suit filed by its foreign creditor.(udi)
--- Lifetime _email_ subscription to all 5 (five) 'apakabar' lists now
available for a one-time donation of US$250 to support Indonesia
Publications' online projects. Email apakabar@radix.net to make all
arrangements. See http://www.indopubs.com for info on these lists. ---